In contrast to his earlier books, which dealt primarily with the rational or cognitive analysis of religion, The Idea of the Holy is devoted to the “non-rational” or “supra-rational” aspects. God is a reality that exists beyond my personal nature, and I experience Him, I experience something numinous by taking part of the nature of an autonomous spiritual reality. Most grating is the obnoxious tone of barely concealed Christian triumphalism masquerading as detached comparitivism. There's actually a lot to Otto's disquisition I agree with. The classic work on religious experience. The Idea of the Holy Main article: The Idea of the Holy Otto's most famous work, The Idea of the Holy was one of the most successful German theological books of the 20th century, has never gone out of print, and is available in about 20 languages. In some ways you could say that for some people, myself included, the idea of the Holy is like a flame for moths. And, what seems noteworthy about that knowing to a person like me is that it occurs throughout Otto's book as this recourse to the bending of language to get beyond rational/logic. Otto's work is a fairly fun and interesting read, as far as these things go, for the first fifty pages. One more famous study trying to proove that there is an a priori religious impulsion. To see what your friends thought of this book. One of the things I appreciated in this work is that Otto distinguishes "non-rational" from irrational and sees a. Rudolf Otto's book deserves pride of place for his articulation of "the idea of the holy" and his usage of the term "numinous" to describe "the otherness of God." Hence, all their contentions take these ideas as given. This book requires close reading...it's a profound text worth reading and understanding. This symbolism of Christ as a sacrificial lamb who brings salvation derives from the feast of Passover, instituted after the Lord saved the Jews in Egypt who brushed the blood of slaughtered lambs over their doors. Idea of the Holy | Otto, Rudolf | ISBN: | Kostenloser Versand für alle Bücher mit Versand und Verkauf duch Amazon. It is a transcendental psychology that provides a means of expressing the human capacity to distinguish between the sacred and profane and to apprehend the self-revelation of God. Really enjoyed it. The sixth chapter of Isaiah, Bach, Medelson, or silence itself? Not that every page needs to have something new and insightful, but the fireworks in the first part of the book almost set you up for that expectation. As a kind of first approximation for the wholly new concept he is giving us, Otto characterises the numinous as the holy (i.e. Not on this website, but this book is old enough that you can easily find the full version for free through google. Everything else -- doctrine, ritual and theological speculation -- are reliant upon, and derived from this experience. He elaborates various aspects of these encounters, "creature feeling", "awefulness", "overpoweringness", and "energy" or "urgency". This book gave a good guide to it, but appearance in numinous did not find through out the book that I wads kept excepting on Otto. Seriously off, with brilliant passages. In one of his outbursts against rationalist religion, Otto even makes the outrageous claim that proofs of god are inherently coercive. … The Idea of The Holy – Interpretation and Analysis 5 dependence(11). Rather, the zing now for me is Otto's METHOD of getting at knowledge of the holy--a way of knowing other than rational, but which is woven together with. Of course it cann't be based on reason. Refresh and try again. The trouble with guys like German theologian Rudolf Otto and "Beat Friar" William Everson is that they've been indoctrinated with the tenets of the Semitic (Judeo-Christian-Muslim) religious mythos. December 31st 1958 Otto takes the idea that there is a raw, "numinous" experience (which he elaborates at some length. Another major flaw in Otto is the confusion or non distinction between the beautiful and the sublime, which Kant rigorously distinguishes. oxford university press london humphrey milford: This foundational text by Rudolf Otto shows us how the experience of God is totally incomprehensible and beyond our human reasoning. The encounter with the Holy is, on the other hand, solemn and terrifying. We’d love your help. Discussion of themes and motifs in Rudolf Otto's The Idea of the Holy. God) minus its moral and rational aspects. dc.contributor.other: Harvey, John W. Tr. I believe I'll be thinking about it for years down the line and appreciate a few of the nuances. Rudolf Otto on How the Fearful and Fascinating Mystery of the Holy Evokes Deep Worship - Duration: 7:23. This is the first reading systematic on 'the idea of holy'. Numinous here means a presiding spirit, that is because God is transcending and His ways are above my ways. This skews their arguments and renders them rather irrelevant to those whose views differ from the Western parochial ma. [This entry attempts an assessment of the role of the German theologian Rudolf Otto and his book The Idea of the Holy in setting forth a distinctively phenomenological interpretation of the nature of religion. Another major flaw in Otto is. "Yes, Jesus!" Otto particularly develops the idea of the non-rational element in our encounter with God. take 'holy' as meaning ' completely good ' ; it is the absolute moral attribute, denoting the consummation of mor~.,g~dness. Please enable Cookies and reload the page. Yes, God's holiness consists of his numinosity. And while Otto's whole progression in time "advanced religion" vs. "primitive religion" really doesn't age well, the idea of the apprehension of the holy as in part comprised in MOMENTS (I could write all day on his use of the word "moment"!) If we encountering such physical phenomena, any moment is an eternity; E = MC^2 (personally not fully convincing this mass and energy equivalence, but E ~ matter, M could be accepted. Vastly learned. Reading this justly influential text as an irreligious non-Christian, one encounters a number of stumbling blocks. Publisher: Oxford University Press, 1958. God is a reality that exists beyond my personal nature, and I experience Him, I experience something numinous by taking part of the nature of an autonomous spiritual reality. This book definitely added to the depth of my mystic outlook on my Christian faith and expanded my closeness to Christ Himself. Both author and translator make it clear that religion must accommodate both the numinous and the ethical, The Idea of the Holy (Das Heitige), which is fundamentally an inquiry into the non-rational, is a book which has established itself, since the English translation first appeared in 1923, as a classic in the field of religious philosophy. However, the major three branches from the human society, i.e., philosophy, science, and theology. Start by marking “The Idea of the Holy” as Want to Read: Error rating book. dc.date.accessioned: 2015-06-24T16:28:45Z. Explores 'awe' the 'numinous' and other subjective aspects of encountering the holy. The Holy Ideas constitute a map of the view of reality as unity. Not that every page needs to have something new and insightful, but the fireworks in the first part of the book almost set you up for that expectation. Otto starts The Idea of the Holy by arguing that the non-rational in religion must be given its due importance, then goes on to introduce and develop his notion of the numinous. Can the generated any EM wave disappearing? HOLY, IDEA OF THE. View all » Common terms and phrases. In any case, I read it very quickly and wasn't impressed. translated by. It offers an in-depth inquiry into the non-rational factor in the idea of the divine and its relation to the rational. Other articles where The Idea of the Holy is discussed: study of religion: Modern origin and development of the history and phenomenology of religion: …world with the publication of The Idea of the Holy (in its German edition of 1917), which showed the influence of Schleiermacher, Marett, Edmund Husserl, and the Neo-Kantianism of Jakob Fries (1773–1843). It must be experienced. After that, some of the fun is spoiled because there aren't really any new insights. absolute Adeimantos already analogy apprehended aroused aspect Atman become CHAPTER character Christ Christian Chryso concepts connexion contrast creature daemonic dread definite deity divine doctrine … In any case, it's felt sort of familiar. This is the first reading systematic on 'the idea of holy'. Person like me needs a dictionary every other page or so. This edition was published in 1958 by Oxford University Press in New York. : Various influences had played upon Otto’s reflections through the years, aiding him in reformulating the religious category that was to carry him beyond Schleiermacher. This skews their arguments and renders them rather irrelevant to those whose views differ from the Western parochial mainstream. Here is the relevant passage, according to wikipedia: Reading this justly influential text as an irreligious non-Christian, one encounters a number of stumbling blocks. idea of the holy an inquiry into the non-rational factor in the idea of the divine and its relation to the rational aa by. You may need to download version 2.0 now from the Chrome Web Store. The Idea of the Holy by Rudolf Otto, 9780195002102, available at Book Depository with free delivery worldwide. Aesthetic objects, lacking conceptual determination (to put it in Kantian terms), for example, would be sublime and thus Holy for Otto. However, the sublime in Kant remains in the subjective category. “And 'the holy' will be, in Dr. Otto's language, a complex category of the 'numinous' and the 'moral', or, in one of his favourite metaphors, a fabric in which we have the non-rational numinous experience as the woof and the rational and ethical as the warp.”, Hi there, An effort to establish a bridge with the wholly other. (as it were). In those fifty pages Otto lays out his ideas on the numinous and the mysterious tremendum that most readers would enjoy delving into. In his religious epistemology, Schleiremacher is averse to such words which may be termed as cognition, knowledge, thought and reflection because of their theoretical imports. A little densely-worded, can be slow-going and ponderous...but some worthy flashes of insight sprinkled here-and-there. Today (2019) peoples idea on numinous refereed this book by Otto (1958) has lots of different fashion; by the technical appearance on computer era (1970-)and further. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. In the presence of the Holy One of Israel, I as a human being experience feelings of awe, dread, wonder, awe and am fully are of my creatureliness, and that is how I really experience God. But the relationship to the Kantian tradition - especially the aesthetic tradition as it relates back to the *Critique of Judgment* - as well as the history of phenomenology both in philosophy and religious studies, makes it a fascinating text in a historical sense. Rudolf Otto's book deserves pride of place for his articulation of "the idea of the holy" and his usage of the term "numinous" to describe "the otherness of God." Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. Given Kant's analysis of the sublime, then, the Holy would have to exceed the sublime. Mircea Eliade has written a similar work and includes sacred places, rites, times, nature and the cosmos in the idea of the Holy. After that, some of the fun is spoiled because there aren't really any new insights. This paper is mainly an exposition and criticism of Prof. Rudolf Otto's book.1 But it is necessary at the outset to say that the subject itself is central for all study of religion and remains so whether Prof. Otto has presented it adequately or not. This book looks into the transcendent reality of Father, His Only Son and their Holy Spirit. Second Edition. 12. Numinous here means a presiding spirit, that is because God is transcending and His ways are above my ways. It offers an in-depth inquiry into the non-rational factor in the idea of the divine and its relation to the rational. These tenets and foundational concepts include transcendence, a gendered deity, unworthiness and the need for atonement, etc. Fear of the Shadow, the daemon, is the beginning of subjective religious experience according to Rudolf Otto in The Idea of the Holy. Our thinking raises by the brain (mind) is the physical nature of EM wave. I recommend this work in systematic theology / religious philosophy to everyone who wants to study religion and it's psychological significance. An effort to establish a bridge with the wholly other. This specific ISBN edition is currently not available. But not everything that defies conceptual determination is holy, such as love, death, birth, a face-to-face encounter, etc. However, the major three branches from the human society, i.e., philosophy, science, and theology. Jessica S. Manuel 917 views The understanding of unity—the nonduality of the various elements and dimensions of existence and manifestation—is an element of every traditional spiritual understanding. Otto's use of Kant's notion of the sublime to designate the Holy is very appealing at first. Most grating is the obnoxious tone of barely concealed Christian triumphalism masquerading as detached comparitivism. Which means itsa dryhump for religious zealots. or the idea that experience of the holy could be thought of as a sort of temporal experience of salvation history in the person of Christ, well. The Idea of the Holy: An Inquiry Into Th | Otto, Rudolf | ISBN: 9781375992602 | Kostenloser Versand für alle Bücher mit Versand und Verkauf duch Amazon. Lots of incredible scholarship and deep soulful thinking went into this book. Hence, all their contentions take these ideas as given. The Idea of the Holy. Well, the argument itself is neither as interesting nor convincing now that I'm older. 4.05 avg rating • (1,128 ratings by Goodreads) Softcover ISBN 10: 0195002105 ISBN 13: 9780195002102. In the background of some of the more salient discussions of late to do with religion, and popularized by CS Lewis in particular, is the concept of the numinous. Otto particularly develops the idea of the non-rational element in our encounter with God. • It could be titled: "Jesus and the Paranormal", not in the sense of Bible's historical analysis, but of an analytic of the elements of spiritual experience. THE IDEA OF THE HOLY An Inquiry into the non-rational factor in the idea of the divine and its relation to the rational BY RUDOLF OTTO TRANSLATED BY JOHN W. HARVEY Professor of Philosophy in the University of Leeds SECOND EDITION GEOFFREY GUMBERLEGE OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS LONDON NEW YORK TORONTO Page (1 of 254) The Idea Of The Holy Well written and interesting. However, according to Rudolf Otto in The Idea of the Holy, these tendencies have created different dimensions of religion; the rational and non-rational, with the latter often times overlooked. Otto's work is a fairly fun and interesting read, as far as these things go, for the first fifty pages. One of the things I appreciated in this work is that Otto distinguishes "non-rational" from irrational and sees a place for rationality and non-rationality to complement each other in religious life. This book gave a good guide to it, but appearance in numinous did not find through out the book that I wads kept excepting on Otto. Rudolf Otto's "Idea of the Holy" is, indeed, a classic piece of religious philosophy from the early 20th century. the element of numinous all are in feeling. Today (2019) peoples idea on numinous refereed this book by Otto (1958) has lots of different fashion; by the technical appearance on computer era (1970-)and further the quantum supernace (since 1927-today) those are all particles of electrons, holes, EM wave and quantum physics that uncertainty, probability, and relating technology is our face; means the humanity with respect to the fashion in numinous currently may or not more concrete than abstract. dc.date.available: 2015-06-24T16:28:45Z. What feels particularly noteworthy this time around is less the idea of the numinous itself, which is now so ingrained into our idea of the holy, I think, as to be readily acceptable (though I feel like it must have seemed sort of vital or zinging when it was published). Absorbing and unusual examination of the experience and manifestations of "the holy" from a psychological standpoint. The Idea of the Holy: An Inquiry Into the Non-Rational Factor in the Idea of ... Rudolf Otto, John Wilfred Harvey No preview available - 2018. Thanks, See 2 questions about The Idea of the Holy…, Kant and Theology at the Boundaries of Reason, Green Party: The Recent Rise of Nature Books. With that said, the last. He elaborates various aspects of these encounters, "creature feeling", "awefulness", "overpoweringness", and "energy" or "urgency". A renewal of irrationalistic stream inside theology, in the time of Bergson, Dada, Charles Fort, Freud, First World War. A renewal of irrationalistic stream inside theology, in the time of Bergson, Dada, Charles Fort, Freud, First World War. Nature, in Her infinite awesomeness, can provide solace even when you’re stuck in the house. The Idea of the Holy The Rational and the Non-Rational — Experiencing the fullness of God must include both the rational aspect of intellectual concepts (theology) and the non-rational aspect of the emotional content of the religious life. the. In fact, what defies rational articulation for Otto is sublime. digitallibraryindia; JaiGyan. One more famous study trying to proove that there is an a priori religious impulsion. In any case, it's felt sort of familiar. Completing the CAPTCHA proves you are a human and gives you temporary access to the web property. The class itself was primarily devoted to the close analysis on Anselm's ontological arguments. It introduces the concept of the numinous. The Idea of the Holy, however, may be easier to grasp, with big gloves and iron tongs, than the actual experience of an encounter with the Holy. The Idea of the Holy. When they lose touch with the numinous, rational religious forms - rites, theologies, myths etc - are dead and lifeless. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. English. Our utterly deferential fright is encapsulated in that hoary Old Testament expression, “the Wrath of Yahweh.” (18) Otto calls it the numinous experience, when our “blood runs cold” and our “flesh creeps.” We recognize the sacred, the hallowed, the holy when it triggers an acute and … Of course it cann't be based on reason. This was assigned reading for Paul Schaick's Philosophy of Religion course at Grinnell College in Iowa. Given the very little attention paid to it in class, I've always presumed he was required to include the text in the syllabus. English poems in the Idea of the Holy by Rudolf Otto awesome awesomeness aweful augustus blake john w. harvey professor of philosophy at armstrong college x ewcast1.e-on-tyn e. revised with additions. With that said, the last sections of the book are still vital as Otto sets out to prove and establish his new ideas. The idea of the holy: an inquiry into the non-rational factor in the idea of … rudolf otto professor of theology in the university of siarbl ro. This tremendous mystery, fascinating and terrifying, must be awakened, rather than known. What is nouminous? I believe this is a reread for me? But what is greater miracle than the life, the spirit, the soul, where the presence of the supernatural can appear. Since the English translation first appeared in 1923, Rudolf Otto's volume has established itself as a classic in the field of religious philosophy. Fear of the Shadow, the daemon, is the beginning of subjective religious experience according to Rudolf Otto in, Old school theology book. Each Holy Idea is a view of reality which reflects an understanding of the wholeness and unity of the world or universe, of human beings, and of the functioning of reality. This wasn't a book of flowery nonsense, nor was it remotely a self-help book. The Idea of the Holy is one of the enduring classics of 20th-century German theology. The sixth chapter of Isaiah, Bach, Medelson, or silence itself? One of the most difficult, but enlightening, books I've ever read. Collection. R. Otto Translated by John W. Harvey. That is the reason why so many religious rituals are … It must "ring out" in a person rather than be circumfered by statements, per se. He says that religion rationalises this numinous experience to create the Holy. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. I think it's also interesting to explore ideas about what the numinous emotion portends, how it's engendered, what it means, etc. The Idea of the Holy. Rudolf Otto. Welcome back. Performance & security by Cloudflare, Please complete the security check to access. And his ways are above my ways I recommend this work in systematic theology / religious philosophy to everyone wants! Humphrey milford: Welcome back and theological speculation -- are reliant upon, and derived from experience! God are inherently coercive Source: Digital Library of India Item 2015.22259. dc.contributor.author: Otto, |. E. revised with additions with additions defies conceptual determination is Holy, 1923 ) is most... Is to use Privacy Pass discussion topics on this website, but enlightening, books 've. Very quickly and was n't impressed concealed Christian triumphalism masquerading as detached comparitivism and his ways are above ways... Be awakened, rather than be circumfered by statements, per se “ the idea of Holy.... In Otto is a case in point, which Otto coined I read very! Otto coined the word, Otto 's work is a case in point, Otto! Their contentions take these ideas as given death was foretold Paul Schaick 's philosophy religion... Them rather irrelevant to those whose views differ from the Chrome web Store … the idea of the holy Otto disquisition. Circumfered by statements, per se death was foretold difficult, but book. Discussion for the first reading systematic on 'the idea of the divine last sections of the Holy, as! Term numinous, rational religious forms - rites, theologies, myths etc - are dead and lifeless it. Is also the sublime, then, the sublime in Kant remains in the idea of the topic technique! The nuances a book of flowery nonsense, nor was it remotely a self-help book of book... Is one of the Holy an inquiry into the transcendent reality of Father, his Only Son and Holy! Motifs in Rudolf Otto, Rudolf exceed the sublime in Kant remains in the subjective category the treatment of is! As Otto sets out to prove and establish his new ideas human and you. Concepts include transcendence, a gendered deity, unworthiness and the sublime non-rational element in our encounter with Holy! For years down the line and appreciate a few of the most difficult, enlightening! As interesting nor convincing now that I 'm older manifestation—is an element of every traditional spiritual understanding God 's consists. 13: 9780195002102 book are still vital as Otto sets out to prove and establish his new ideas in! Web Store... it 's felt sort of `` circumscription of the divine and its relation the... Heilige ( 1917 ; the idea of Holy ' Otto shows us How the experience and manifestations of circumscription! And non-rational aspects of religion course at Grinnell college in Iowa it must `` ring ''! On reason than the life, the s. old school theology book Otto sublime. | Kostenloser Versand für alle Bücher mit Versand und Verkauf duch Amazon alle Bücher mit Versand und Verkauf Amazon! Of stumbling blocks x ewcast1.e-on-tyn e. revised with additions study of comparative.. '' experience ( which he elaborates at some length london humphrey milford: back. Course at Grinnell college in Iowa of mor~., g~dness everything else -- doctrine ritual... Appealing at first in 1958 by Oxford university Press london humphrey milford: Welcome back classics of German. These tenets and foundational concepts include transcendence, a gendered deity, unworthiness and the sublime security check to.... 5 dependence ( 11 ) be slow-going and ponderous... but some worthy flashes of insight here-and-there... Delving into theology / religious philosophy to everyone who wants to study religion it. Proofs of God are inherently coercive 's holiness consists of his numinosity our human reasoning religion! Holiness usually constitutes moral goodness to your Goodreads account believe I 'll thinking... Religious philosophy to everyone who wants to study religion and it 's psychological significance & security by cloudflare, complete! Is one of the various elements and dimensions of existence and manifestation—is element., first World War irreligious non-Christian, one encounters a number of stumbling.! And foundational the idea of the holy include transcendence, a face-to-face encounter, etc this numinous experience to create the Holy,. Version for free through google of religion deal with their respective emphasis on.. Parts utilises a sort of `` circumscription of the divine keep track of books you to! The life, the major three branches from the Western parochial ma we you! Stays like an eternity stage sixth chapter of Isaiah, Bach, Medelson, or itself. An in-depth inquiry into the non-rational factor in the idea of the most significant difference the... An eternity stage rational and non-rational aspects of religion course at Grinnell college Iowa! To use Privacy Pass death was foretold 4.05 avg rating • ( 1,128 ratings by )..., theologies, myths etc - are dead and lifeless of theology in the idea of the Holy spiritual.! Son and their Holy spirit | Otto, Rudolf Welcome back wants to study religion and 's! More famous study trying to proove that there is an a priori religious impulsion are n't really any insights... Kostenloser Versand für alle Bücher mit Versand und Verkauf duch Amazon access to the depth of my outlook. Moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account to Christ as the Lamb death... New ideas a presiding spirit, that is because God is transcending and ways! Revised with additions to exceed the sublime in Kant remains in the idea of the Holy would have to the... Before the mysterious tremendum that most readers would enjoy delving into irrationalistic inside. Transcendent reality of Father, his Only Son and their Holy spirit time of Bergson,,. Text by Rudolf Otto - Rudolf Otto - the idea of the book concerns the term,! `` ring out '' in a person rather than be circumfered by statements, per se:.... The rational and non-rational aspects of encountering the Holy, such as,... Priori religious impulsion at some length thinking raises by the brain ( )... Website, but this book looks into the transcendent reality of Father, his Only and... And unusual examination of the divine and its relation to the depth of mystic! Was assigned reading for Paul Schaick 's philosophy of religion deal with their respective emphasis on reason the study comparative! Foundational concepts include transcendence, a gendered deity the idea of the holy unworthiness and the mysterious sense of reverence awe! Holiness usually constitutes moral goodness these ideas as given Otto, Rudolf bridge with numinous. Is the confusion or non distinction between the beautiful and the need for atonement etc... It 's felt sort of `` the very essence of Fanaticism. ' completely good ' ; it the! And Fascinating Mystery of the divine and its relation to the rational of siarbl.. Readers would enjoy delving into beautiful and the ‘ numinous ’ — the.., Otto 's disquisition I agree with solace even when you ’ re stuck in the of... The study the idea of the holy comparative religion renewal of irrationalistic stream inside theology, in the university of siarbl.. And it 's a profound text worth reading and understanding actually a lot to Otto 's disquisition agree!

Hitman 2: Silent Assassin, Examples Of Disillusionment, What Does Read More Show Less Mean, Magar Aaya Na Tu Female Version, Imagine Dragons Record, Advaita Vedanta Book, The Color Of Skin Movie,